noTOMy, hto « pa3rpaHHHeHHe 4>o»eM Ij, h H aBjiaeTca cjia6biM sbchom (J)0HeTH-HeCKOÍÍ CHCTeMbI CJiaBHHCKHX H3blK0B. MMeHHO TaKHe CJia6bie 3BeUbH H «nopa-»aioTCH» npewAe Bcero b cjiyHaax a3biKOBbix CMemeHHH» (cTp. 300). He 6y,ny npMBOAHTb anajiorHHHbix MecT H3 apyrHX pa6oT.
    B 1956 ro/ty MHe npmiuiocb BbicTynHTb Ha flOKTopcKOM .HHcnyTe B. T. Opjio-boíí, KOTopaa samumajia auccepTaiiHio Hcmopun acficfipmam e pyccKOM R3HKe e C6H3U c o6pa3oeaHueM pyccKux napodHbix zoeopoe. B 1959 ro/iy ,gnccepTaiina 6biJia 0ny6jiHK0BaHa. OHa H3BecTHa A. Bpany. B. I\ OpjiOBa cTpeMHjiacb 3amH-THTb B3rjIH/I, COrJiaCHO KOTOpOMy UOKaHbe B pyccKOM H3bIKe B03HHKJI0 no BHy-TpeHHMM 3aKOHaM pa3BHTHH H3blKa, CnOHTaHHO, BHe B03fleñCTBHH H3bIKOB HHOÍÍ (J)OHeTHHecKOH CHCTeMbI. Ha AHcnyTe a BbicTynHji npoTHB 3Toro Te3«ca h sauiH-maji THnoTe3y, corjiacHO KOTopoñ uoKaHbe bo3hhkjio b pyccKHx roBopax noa B03ueíicTBHeM 4>HHHO-yropcKoro cyñcTpaTa. Moñ 0T3biB Ha zwccepTauHK) no npHHHTOMy oóbiHaio He 6biJi ony&iiHKOBaH, ho 6ojibuiHe H3BJieHeHHa H3 Hero 0ny6jiHK0Baji npo<}). B. H. JImtkhh b peueH3HH Ha M0H0rpa<j)HK> B. I\ Opjioboíí. npHMenaTejibHo, hto A. Bpany 3HaK0M c stoíi peueH3Heñ. Oh ee UHTftpyeT Ha CTp. 72—73. Bot 0flH0 H3BjieHeHHe H3 peueH3HH npo4>. JlbiTKHHa: ,,B cb»3H c 3thm cjie^yeT BcnoMHHTb cjioBa npo({>. C. B. BepHiHTeHHa, cKa3aHHbie Ha AHcnyTe npn 3amHTe ,anccepTaunn B. Y. OpjioBoíi (paccMaTpHBaeMaa pa6oTa (J)HrypHpo-Ba/ia KaK floiaopcKaa AHceepTauna): « HapyuieHHe b CHCTeMe ciiaBHHCKoro koh-coHaHTH3Ma muría mero h CBHCTamero panoB He aBjiaeTca peajunauHeñ 3aKOHOB npacjiaBHHCKoro nepnoua, a bo3hhkjio b hctophh roBopoB oTAejibnux cjiaBaHcicHX a3bIKOB B CBH3H C pa3HHHHbIMH npHHHH3MH H OÓCTOaTeJIbCTBaMH ». IlpOfJ). BepH-uiTeiíH npofloJiacaeT: « B. r. OpjioBa othocht B03HHKH0BeHHe uoicaHbH b pyccKOM a3biKe k oHera» apeBHeMy nepwofly h yTBepacaaeT, hto oho bo3hhkjio BHe BjiHaHH» <j)HHCKHX K3bIKOB, Ha OCHOBe BHyTpeHHHX 3aKOHOB pa3BHTH» (J)OHeTHHeCKOH CHCTeMbI. Ho TaKoe 3aaBJieHHe o6a3biBaeT aBTopa cepbe3Ho nepecMOTpeTb Becb komiuickc B0np0C0B, CB»3aHHbIH C HCTOpHeH CJiaBaHCROTO KOHCOHaHTH3Ma He TOJIbKO B upeBHepyccKHX roBopax X—XI bb., ho h b npacjiaBancKOM 5i3biKe. Abtop stoto He caeaaji. fl03T0My ero yTBepayieHHe noBHcaeT b B03/iyxe »“ (cm. HAH OJlíl, XX, Bbin. 1, CTp. 86). Bonpocy npoHcxoacaeHHa uoKaHba a npHflaio 6ojibinoe 3HaneHHe. Bot noneMy a BbiHywüen /ma B0CCTaH0BjieHHa hcthhm UHTHpoBaTb ce6a 6ojibiue, HeacejiH MHe 6bi xoTejiocb stoto. Ho BHHOBaT b 3tom He a, a moh ücckhíí onnoHeHT.
    B nocjieAHHe roflbi noaBHJiocb mhoto hobmx aaHHbix o pyccKOM uoKaHbe. floueHT MeJiaÓHHCKoro neflarorHHecKoro HHCTHTyTa I\ A. Typ6HH co6paji h o6pa6oTaji oneHb ueHHbiñ MaTepwaji, xapaKTeproyiomHH pacnpocrpaHeHHe iioicaHba b pyccKHx roBopax Ypajia. M stot MaTepnaji eme h eme pa3 no/iTBepwjiaeT, hto pyCCKOe UOKaHbe BCIOfly B03HHKajI0 BO B3aHMOileÍÍCTBHH C HeCJiaBaHCKHMH a3bIKaMH.